That template is from Fantastico...A lot of people know this and will not use a company that can not afford to have a website designed for them...This tells them that your company is not that stable and you need all the $ you can get to just keep your server(s) up.

Spend $50-$100 on a design and go with that...Have the order form match the design so it gives the expression that their still on the site. This will help boost sales.

Just my opinion on the matter