New Site Design (feedback requested)

I like them both, the new one a little more than the old one. I have to agree with your web designer though, because there seems to be lot of text in the middle there. Maybe add an imge or two?
 
Well his comments were it's too busy, change the logo font/style and remove the chick. And he didnt like all the colors. He said the color made it too busy.
 
Top